The Peace Maker, which was printed for Udney Hay Jacob by the Times and Seasons printing office in Nauvoo, is very significant in the story of how polygamy entered the LDS Church, because much of the pamphlet's theology was woven into the LDS doctrines by Brigham Young and his coworkers. A number of writers have alleged that Joseph had Jacob write the pamphlet to be circulated among the Saints to see if they would tolerate the doctrine of polygamy. Existing evidence shows that Joseph did not collaborate with Jacob in compiling and printing The Peace Maker, and that the theory that he had Jacob do it to test the Saints is entirely false. As discussed in the previous chapter of Joseph Smith Fought Polygamy, the Prophet made a very strong attack on The Peace Maker soon after it was published, by printing:
Morgan Provided Information Concerning a Copy of The Peace MakerOn March 3,1963, we, the authors, purchased a microfilm copy of Udney Hay Jacob's pamphlet, The Peace Maker, from the Utah State Historical Society in Salt Lake City. We found that a "Note" had been added at the beginning of The Peace Maker, which gives information about it and the Jacob family. It is presumed that this note was added by Mr. Dale L. Morgan, to whom we are indebted for his having made a copy, from which ours was made. The note explains:
The note begins with a statement which implicates the Prophet Joseph in the production of the pamphlet, and questions his honesty and integrity by stating:
To suggest that making a judgment as to the authorship of the pamphlet hinges "on what can be learned of Jacob" rather than on Joseph's published denial, is to be unfair to Joseph. The failure to give credence to the Prophet's denial suggests a belief that the founder of the Church was dishonest. Joseph's testimony on this subject has been ignored by most writers. They have insisted that Joseph had Udney write the pamphlet to advance polygamy in the Church, in spite of there being proof that he never was associated with Udney. And Jacob's declaration of authorship has also been ignored— for he asserted, "The author of this work is not a Mormon, although it is printed by their press. It [the Times and Seasons printing office] was the most convenient" (ibid., 3). What Has Been Learned of JacobSince the writer of the "Note" suggested that the decision of authorship of The Peace Maker "hinges rather on what can be learned of Jacob," some knowledge of his history is necessary: Udney's son, Norton Jacob, kept a journal in which he recorded a history of the Udney Jacob family. Norton's journal and the "Archive Record" in the Genealogical Society in Salt Lake City agree that Udney was born April 24, 1781, at Sheffield, Berkshire County, Massachusetts. He married Elizabeth Hubbard, and Norton (their first son) was born in Massachusetts in 1804. The Jacob family lived in Massachusetts and New York before moving to Illinois. By the early 1830s, Udney and his wife, their children and their families, had settled in Hancock County, Illinois, in the village of Pilot Grove Corners, also known as Jacob Corners. Soon after the Saints settled at Nauvoo in 1839, missionaries were sent to eastern Hancock County where Udney resided. He was violently opposed to the missionaries and their gospel message. In 1840 he wrote a letter to President Van Buren in which he expressed anger and disdain for Joseph Smith, Sidney Rigdon, and the Church. So great was his opposition to the Saints that he appealed to the president for finances to print his book, which he said would assure Van Buren of a political victory, and would defeat those candidates whom the Saints favored. Norton Was Persecuted for Joining the Church
At that time, Norton Jacob was the only member of the Jacob family who believed the good news of the gospel. He wrote in his journal:
An article appeared in the Church's paper on the subject of the success of Elder Gurley's missionary work at La Harpe. It was reported:
After the Prophet's death, Seventy Zenos Gurley, Sr., became prominent in the Reorganized Church, where he served for years as an apostle. In 1843, Udney Jacob joined the Church; however, a difficulty arose in the Pilot Grove Branch which caused Udney to request that his name be removed from the Church record. He was rebaptized November 2,1845, by Norton, and confirmed by Norton, who was assisted by Zenos Gurley (see The Record of Norton Jacob, 12). Joseph Was Exonerated in the Millennial StarIn 1850, six years after the Prophet's death, the Millennial Star, a Church paper started in England during Joseph's lifetime, upheld the Prophet's testimony pertaining to The Peace Maker. The letter, which was written by Eli B. Kelsey to Apostle Orson Pratt, head of the European Mission under Brigham Young's leadership, was printed in the Star. The title of the article which contained the letter, "A Base Calumny Refuted," is an affirmation in itself to Joseph's innocence. The letter stated:
Jacob Admitted to Brigham Young that He Wrote The Peace MakerIn March 1851, Udney Jacob wrote a letter to Brigham Young in which he stated that he had written The Peace Maker. After being rebaptized in 1845, Udney had followed Brigham Young to Utah, where he was ordained a high priest.
An incident occurred in Salt Lake City which caused Udney to feel it was necessary to make a statement to President Young about The Peace Maker. An individual, who signed himself "Elijah," wrote some papers and posted them on the Bowery, which was an outside meeting place where preaching services were held. Evidently Brigham Young and other leaders were not pleased with Elijah's message. In attempting to discover the identity of the author of the papers, it was recalled that within The Peace Maker Jacob had declared himself to be Elijah. This made him a prime suspect. Jacob was informed that President Young suspected him of being the one who posted the papers at the Bowery. To dispel all doubt of his involvement, he wrote President Brigham Young, saying:
Once again it is evident that Jacob testified that he wrote The Peace Maker, which agreed with Joseph's declaration that he knew nothing of the pamphlet until after its publication. Jacob and Joseph's testimonies agree! But the majority of writers in the past have ignored the testimonies of both men in their efforts to convict Joseph of the crime of polygamy. John D. Lee Proclaimed the "Feeler" TheoryIn spite of the many evidences that the Prophet had no part in The Peace Maker, the rumor remained alive and grew among the LDS Church members. An example of this is found in the biography of Bishop John D. Lee, who was executed for his part in the Mountain Meadows Massacre. Lee said:
Lee gave no references to support his allegations against the Prophet. However, there was no way that he could truthfully reference his statement that "during the winter" Joseph directed Udney to write a pamphlet to "pave the way for celestial marriage." Which winter did Lee have reference to? It could not have been the winter of 1838–1839, for Joseph was in Missouri that entire winter—a prisoner in the Liberty Jail. Or, was Lee inferring that Joseph directed Jacob to write the pamphlet in the winter of 1839–1840? Such was also impossible because Joseph was not in Nauvoo that winter either. The Prophet moved to Commerce (Nauvoo) in May 1839, and left there on October 29, 1839, to journey to Washington, D.C., to seek redress for losses suffered by the Saints in Missouri. The Prophet arrived home just fifteen days before Udney wrote his March 19, 1840, letter to President Van Buren, informing him that he had a manuscript [The Peace Maker] ready for publication. Udney's manuscript was evidently lengthy, for the extract published at Nauvoo was taken only from chapters eighteen and nineteen. The extract consisted of thirty-seven pages—so if the other chapters were of the same length, the manuscript could have been over three hundred pages. This would have taken Udney months or years to research and write in longhand. It should be remembered that Bishop John D. Lee was Brigham Young's adopted son. Young's will was Lee's will. Lee's statement is an example of the propolygamist's development and use of the false theory which states that Joseph had Udney write The Peace Maker to see how the Saints would respond to polygamy. There is another statement by Lee in the above, which is of major importance. His assertion that "... at the same time [that The Peace Maker was published] other confidential men [men other than Joseph] were advocating it [polygamy] on their own responsibility." This, of course, included Brigham Young and others, who were already either secretly practicing or advocating polygamy. Fawn Brodie Unquestioningly Accepted the "Feeler" TheoryFawn M. Brodie also gave credence to the false theory as late as 1945 in her book No Man Knows My History. She was one of the most noted of a number of writers who published an alleged expose of Joseph's life, emphasizing the sensational. Her book has been hailed as one of the best-written and most authentic documentation of Joseph's life. However, she followed the same line as popular writers by declaring that Joseph was a polygamist. She failed to consider the possibility that Joseph could have been telling the truth when he denounced The Peace Maker. In reference to it, Brodie wrote:
Brodie made the charge that Joseph "was quickly forced to denounce" the pamphlet, without giving her source for that charge. In what way was the Prophet forced? There is no evidence that the Saints blamed Joseph for the publication of the pamphlet on the Church's press, for it was common knowledge that the Twelve, and not the Prophet, were in charge of the publishing arm of the Church at that time. It is evident that the Prophet denounced Udney's pamphlet of his own free will because he found it to be, as he declared, "an unmeaning rigmarole of nonsense, folly, and trash." Brodie's charge was unfounded and false. Imogene Goodyear's Use of The Peace MakerIn 1983, the Liberal Revisionists, who had taken control of the RLDS Church, were secretly making an effort to discard all Restoration distinctives and turn the Church into a liberal, Protestant denomination. One step in accomplishing this goal was to discredit Joseph Smith—for if the Saints should lose confidence in him, the rest would be easy. Accordingly, Church Historian Richard P. Howard wrote a paper, which was approved by the Church's Joint Council, entitled "The Changing RLDS Response to Mormon Poly gamy: A Preliminary Analysis" (The John Whitmer Historical Association Journal 3 [1983]: 14–29). In the paper, Howard stated that the RLDS belief had changed from the belief that Joseph was innocent of polygamy to now believing that he was the author of it. The paper was read in 1983 at a meeting of the John Whitmer Historical Society Association, and Imogene Goodyear made a "response" to it. At the time Goodyear, also a Revisionist, was "a member of the Editorial Department at Herald Publishing House" (see Imogene Goodyear, "Joseph Smith and Polygamy: An Alternative View," John Whitmer Historical Society Journal 4 [1984]: 16). In her analysis she agreed with Howard's stance of branding Joseph a polygamist, and referred to The Peace Maker as proof. Goodyear wrote:
The suggestion that The Peace Maker was written, or printed, by Joseph as an evidence of Joseph's reaction "to the women's movement" is without foundation. What Imogene Goodyear did not consider, or explore, was the possibility that a "rationale for temple sealing ceremonies connected in part with polygamy" was the work of Brigham Young and those leaders who thought and believed as he did— and not Joseph's work—as the Mormons and the Community of Christ leaders choose to believe. They have never addressed the possibility that Joseph was honest, and that his denials of involvement with polygamy were words of truth. Lawrence Foster Stressed the "Feeler" TheoryImogene Goodyear quoted from a book by Lawrence Foster in which he called The Peace Maker a "brilliant" and "remarkable thirty-seven-page pamphlet defending polygamy" (Lawrence Foster, Religion and Sexuality—The Shakers, the Mormons, and the Oneida Community [Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1984], 174). Foster stated that the authorship of The Peace Maker was "deliberately vague" (which it definitely was not) and implied that Udney was in "a leadership position in the Church" (ibid.,174–175), while the evidence shows that he was not a member, and had not even met Joseph when the pamphlet was published. Foster stated that "Smith mildly dissociated himself from the publication in a brief statement in the Times and Seasons," and that "the pamphlet was put forward as a 'feeler' to test Church opinion but was disowned when public reaction proved too unfavorable" (ibid., 175–176). The failure by many to consider the possibility that Joseph's testimony about The Peace Maker could be relied on, demonstrates how much the Prophet's character, his integrity and honesty, has been damaged by those who charged him with introducing polygamy. A Chronological Account of Joseph and Jacob's ActivitiesSince incorrect beliefs seem to never die (such as believing that Joseph had Udney write The Peace Maker to test the Saints' tolerance for polygamy), the following time line is provided. It shows that Joseph and Udney could not have cooperated in producing that pamphlet, because they were never together while it was being written:
The ConclusionThis chronological listing is additional proof that Joseph and Udney did not know each other before The Peace Maker was published; and therefore, Joseph did not "set" Udney to write The Peace Maker. They did not have the time to work together on the manuscript—they did not even know each other. The "feeler" theory was developed and perpetuated by those who wanted to make polygamy a doctrine of the Church, with Joseph as its author. It did not matter how many times Joseph bore a testimony against polygamy. There were those who wanted to believe he was the author of it, so they chose not to believe that he spoke the truth. However, it can no longer be denied that there is ample evidence which shows agreement between the testimonies of Udney Jacob and Joseph Smith—that Joseph had no part in producing The Peace Maker.
[ Joseph Smith Fought Polygamy Index ]
Joseph Smith Fought Polygamy—Volume I, by Richard and Pamela Price, can be purchased at the Restoration Bookstore or from our online store. Articles on this subject continue to be published in Vision magazine, which also can be purchased at the Restoration Bookstore or online. It is planned that this additional material will be compiled into future volumes. For a general understanding of both the origins of polygamy among the Latter Day Saints and the several conspiracies to falsely implicate Joseph in polygamy, read the article on our Web site, "Joseph Smith: Innocent of Polygamy," by Richard Price. |
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||